Former Miss Titleholders:
2018 - Megan Kelly
2017 - Emily Payne
2016 - Chersten Sandvik
2015 - Shannon Singleton
2014 - Courtney Ford
2013 - Brianna Abarca
2012 - Kilyawhii Linton
2011 - Grace Woolley
2010 - Kayla Lawler
2009 - Brittany Onder
2008 - Rachel McAllister
2007 - Kelly Haynes
2006 - Ashleigh Schulte
2005 - Alisa Hansen
2004 - Sarah McAllister
2003 - Lauren LeVine
2002 - Tahnee Seevers
2001 - Erica Gugliemetti
2000 - Janelle Castrejon
1999 - Amber Lynn Scott
1998 - Stephanie LeRoy
1997 - Leandra Edwards
1996 - Jennifer Brewster
1995 - Anjeanette Ohm
1994 - Jill Smith
1993 - Christine Quinones
1992 - Whitney DiPaolo
1991 - Janet Niederheiser
1990 - Erica Mitchell
1989 - Linette Leppink
1988 - Deanna Ely
1987 - Linda Lynch
1986 - Tara Clark
1985 - Jennifer Lynch
1984 - Mary Vrooman
1983 - Andrea James
1982 - Kelly Collins
1981 - Marjie Thomsen
1980 - Anna Marie Finitzer
1979 - Tammie Souza
1978 - Kathy Barger
1977 - Carie Temple
1976 - Debbie Watkins
1975 - Donna King
1974 - Karen Dalton
1973 - Brenda Lawrence
1972 - Kathy Dalton
1971 - Arlene Tippets
1969 - Kathy Tippets
1968 - Judy Richardson
1959 - Shirlee Brown - Also Fairest of the Fair, Miss San Diego County
1957 - Linda McIntosh
1956 - Helen Ruth Starnes
1955 - Evelyn Richardson
1949 - Lorraine Jones - First Miss Ramona to compete in the Fairest of the Fair Pageant
Turkey Day Queens:
1935 - Gertrude Wilson (Page)
1938 - Dottie Richardson (McIntosh)
1939 - Elinor Smith (Shadeck)
1940 - Teddy Riddle (Klatt),
1941 - Kay Kendal (Brister)