Former Teen Titleholders:
2018 - Makenna Hyland
2017 - Cheyenne Dephilippis
2016 - Ashley Dominguez
2015 - Megan Kelly
2014 - Elizabeth Bowersox
2013 - Shannon Singleton
2012 - Chersten Sandvik
2011 - Andrea Proctor
Former Teen Titleholders:
2018 - Makenna Hyland
2017 - Cheyenne Dephilippis
2016 - Ashley Dominguez
2015 - Megan Kelly
2014 - Elizabeth Bowersox
2013 - Shannon Singleton
2012 - Chersten Sandvik
2011 - Andrea Proctor